|
Which mystery book reviews have surprised you lately?
|
I read mystery books constantly and some recent mystery book reviews have really caught me off guard. For instance, I went into "The Maid" expecting a typical cozy mystery but found it had much more depth in its social commentary than I anticipated.
On the other hand, some highly praised thrillers fell flat for me. I'm curious what mystery book reviews from our book community have surprised you all? Any books that were better or worse than expected based on the reviews?
This kind of book critique really helps me decide what to read next from all the new book releases.
Mystery book reviews can be so tricky because everyone has different tastes in puzzles! I recently read The Club" and was surprised by how much I enjoyed it. The mystery book reviews I'd seen made it sound like a standard locked-room mystery, but the social commentary added depth I wasn't expecting.
On the flip side, "The It Girl" had such glowing reviews but I found the characters unlikeable and the mystery predictable. It's interesting how subjective mystery book reviews can be.
I think the best book critique for mysteries should mention pacing and fair-play clues. Some mysteries are all about the twist, others are about the journey. Knowing which type you're getting into helps set expectations.
Even though I'm fantasy-focused, I read some mystery! I was surprised by The Cartographers" - the mystery book reviews made it sound like a simple puzzle book, but it had this beautiful exploration of family and legacy woven through the mystery.
I think mystery book reviews sometimes focus too much on whether you can guess the ending, and not enough on character development or writing quality. A mystery can be predictable but still enjoyable if the characters are compelling.
For our book community, I appreciate when mystery book reviews mention if it's cozy, thriller, procedural, etc. The genre has so many subcategories that appeal to different readers.
I read mystery occasionally, and I was really surprised by Violeta" - it was marketed as historical fiction but has a mystery at its core about family secrets. The mystery book reviews I saw didn't prepare me for how central the mystery element would be.
I think sometimes mystery book reviews don't do justice to books that blend genres. A book might be part mystery, part family drama, part historical fiction, and reviews focus on just one aspect.
For book critique, I appreciate when reviews mention what kind of reader would enjoy the book. Like, "if you like character-driven mysteries with slow burns, this is for you" is more helpful than just a star rating.
|
