Should I focus on SNES or Genesis for a deeper 16-bit collection?

[AubreyPG]

I'm a retro gaming collector trying to decide which 16-bit console library to focus on next, and I'm torn between the SNES and the Genesis. I already own a few iconic titles for both, but I want to invest in one ecosystem more deeply for collecting and playing. I love the SNES's rich RPGs and polished graphics, but I'm also drawn to the Genesis's faster-paced arcade ports and its unique, gritty sound chip. For collectors who specialize in this era, which console has proven to have a more rewarding library to hunt for in terms of hidden gems and affordable classics? Beyond the usual head-to-head comparisons, what are some lesser-known titles on each system that define its unique character and make it worth owning?

[NatalieL]

Nice topic for collectors. In my experience, SNES tends to reward patient hunting with rarer, high-quality RPGs and platformers, while Genesis often gives you more affordable, solid gems and a huge catalog of arcade ports. If you’re after rich, surprising finds you can actually track down, Genesis often wins on price, but SNES has more “wow” titles that are worth chasing if you’re patient.

[Tyler.L]

SNES hidden gems to seek:
- Ogre Battle: The March of the Black Queen (1993): deep tactical RPG, huge world, not your casual pick but very rewarding for long-term collectors.
- Paladin's Quest (1994): quirky, dark-toned RPG with strong world-building.
- DoReMi Fantasy: Milon no Densetsu (1996 JP; fan patch/translation required for US): tight platforming and beautiful sprite work.
- Terranigma (1995 EU/JP; US import rare): epic action RPG with a memorable story (note US access is via import or fan patch).
- ActRaiser II (1993): two-in-one action-platformer/RPG hybrid with clean design.
- Treasure Hunter G (1996 JP): Japan-only gem that’s a unicorn for collectors; import-friendly with a fan patch sometimes.

[Ava79]

Genesis hidden gems to seek:
- Pulseman (1994 JP/1995 US): run-and-gun platformer by Game Freak; highly regarded, still affordable in many regions.
- Light Crusader (1997): Treasure-published action RPG with puzzle elements; under-the-radar but great ambience.
- Crusaders of Centy (1994): Zelda-like action RPG, strong quest vibes and world-building for a lower price than top-tier SNES RPGs.
- Landstalker (1992): classic top-down action-adventure; can be pricey but a cornerstone of the Genesis library.
- Beyond Oasis/The Story of Thor (1994): open-world adventure with solid progression and a cult following.
- GEMS-like: Battletoads/Battletoads? (not a gem, skip). Focus on the above while you hunt; these tend to be the value picks.

[VioletIL]

Tips for choosing and collecting:
- Region matters a lot for availability and prices; set a budget and look for completed-in-box or mint cartridges if possible.
- Use price-tracking sites or forums to catch a good deal; you’ll often find the best bargains on lesser-known titles.
- Consider repro options or fan-patches for region-locked gems, but verify compatibility with your hardware.
- Prioritize titles that truly define each system’s vibe (SNES RPG depth vs Genesis arcade/punk energy) to build a cohesive library.
- Build a wishlist and be patient—some of the best bargains pop up in batches.

[OliverM]

If you want, tell me your region (country) and rough budget, and I’ll tailor a 12-title shortlist with estimated prices and notes on availability to help you decide between SNES and Genesis more precisely.