Is the director of that 80s cult sci-fi the right choice for the reboot?

[Ryan73]

I just saw the announcement that the director of that beloved cult sci-fi film from the 80s is attached to helm the long-gestating reboot, and I have deeply mixed feelings. On one hand, their visual style seems perfect, but their recent track record with big studio franchises has been inconsistent at best. The original is so tied to its practical effects and specific era that a modern reinterpretation feels risky. What's everyone's take on this news? Are you cautiously optimistic that a visionary director can bring something new, or does this feel like another unnecessary nostalgia grab that's likely to miss what made the original special?