I'm putting together a retro game collection and I've reached a point where I need to decide between investing more deeply into the NES or SNES library, as I can't realistically collect for both right now. I love the raw, challenging simplicity of classic NES titles, but I'm also drawn to the SNES for its more advanced graphics, sound, and the depth of its iconic RPGs. For collectors and players who have experience with both systems, what are the defining strengths and weaknesses of each library beyond the obvious technical leap? Is the NES's charm and historical significance more rewarding in the long run, or does the SNES's broader genre variety and more polished gameplay hold up better for someone who didn't grow up with either console?
NES has bite-sized, arcade-y magic; SNES brings breadth and depth. If you can only pick one, SNES tends to age better for a casual collector, but the NES library is a joy to own for its history and tight design.
As a collector, I found NES carts easier to track and cheaper; SNES titles can be pricier and harder to find boxed, but the RPGs and platformers on SNES are timeless. If you mainly want games you can play today, SNES wins; if you want a snapshot of Nintendo's early era and the pspark of arcade vibes, NES is essential.
Defining strengths and weaknesses: NES shines with precise, reflex-based action, tight level design, and iconic arcade-style ports, but it often lacks the polish and storytelling breadth of later systems. SNES offers larger worlds, richer music and visuals, and a wider variety of genres (RPGs, action-adventure, platformers and shooters). The trade-off is higher price, more cluttered market, and region quirks that can trip a collector. In short: NES for focus and craft, SNES for breadth and depth.
Must-have lists to start: NES — Super Mario Bros. 3, Mega Man 2, Castlevania III, Metroid, Ninja Gaiden. SNES — A Link to the Past, Chrono Trigger, Super Metroid, Final Fantasy VI, Secret of Mana. If you want a third option, EarthBound on SNES is a cult classic but not everyone’s cup of tea.
If you’re torn, consider a ‘one-system primary, one-or-two key gets’ approach: make SNES your core for RPGs and platformers, then cherry-pick essential NES titles that define the era and provide punchy, quick-play sessions. It’s both nostalgic and practical, and you’ll still have a broad experience without double-dipping.
You could also look at your backlog through a lens of playstyle: do you enjoy tight reflex games or slow-burn exploration? If you lean action, NES has the hits you’ll dog-ear; if you crave world-building and story, SNES has the crown jewels. Either way, you’ll likely come away with a strong, well-rounded collection.