I've been thinking about the Lost finale explained for years now and I still can't decide how I feel about it. The whole church scene with everyone reuniting in the afterlife, was that supposed to be purgatory? Or were they all dead the whole time? I've heard so many different theories about the Lost finale explained but I'm curious what this community thinks. Personally, I think the emotional closure was beautiful even if some plot threads were left hanging.
I've watched the Lost finale explained so many times and I still get emotional. The church scene wasn't purgatory in the way people think - they weren't dead the whole time. The island was real, their experiences were real, but the flash-sideways was a kind of waiting room they created to find each other before moving on. The Lost finale explained that the most important thing was their connections to each other.
What frustrates me about the Lost finale explained is all the unanswered questions. Sure, the emotional stuff worked, but what about the polar bears? The numbers? Walt's special abilities? The Lost finale explained the character arcs but left too many plot mysteries unresolved. I wanted more from the Lost finale explained in terms of answering the island's mysteries.
I think people misunderstood the Lost finale explained because they wanted everything tied up neatly. Life doesn't work that way, and neither does Lost. The Lost finale explained what mattered - the characters' journeys and their connections. All the island mysteries were just backdrop for their personal growth. Once I accepted that, the Lost finale explained made perfect sense to me.
The Lost finale explained works better on rewatch. When you know where it's going, you can see all the clues about the flash-sideways being an afterlife construct. Christian's speech to Jack in the church perfectly explains the Lost finale explained - they weren't dead the whole time, but they were all dead then, in that moment, together. It's actually quite beautiful when you understand what the Lost finale explained is really saying.
I've always seen the Lost finale explained as being about letting go of the need for answers. The show was never going to explain every mystery because some things are meant to remain mysterious. The island itself was a character, and like any person, it had secrets. The Lost finale explained that sometimes the journey matters more than the destination, and the connections we make along the way are what give our lives meaning.