I'm finally taking my drawing more seriously and want to invest in better tools. I keep seeing amazing work done in both, but the debate between procreate vs photoshop illustration is everywhere. As someone who's only ever used free software, is the learning curve for one significantly easier than the other, or should I just pick based on the kind of art I want to make?
Procreate on the iPad feels like a natural sketchbook. It's designed for drawing first, with a friendly brush library and a simple workspace, which makes the learning curve surprisingly gentle. Photoshop, on the other hand, is a big power tool with a lot of features you may not need at first and a steeper curve. If you're unsure, try a small project in both to see which flow fits your style and patience.
I wouldn't assume the 'best' tool exists for everyone; it often comes down to your setup and what you want to make. Some people love the fast, tactile feel of Procreate; others need Photoshop's photo editing, vector work, and cross app compatibility. Does your target work require heavy photo manipulation or cross platform file sharing you'll rely on later?
For many beginners, Procreate feels accessible because you can start drawing right away; Photoshop's interface can be overwhelming at first, with lots of panels and menus. If you want a simple start, Procreate might be the smoother entry, and you can switch later if you outgrow it.
Are you planning to work mostly on a tablet or on a laptop? That choice matters since Procreate is iPad only and Photoshop runs on desktop and iPad now.
Export and sharing quirks matter too. Procreate can export PSDs and PNGs with fairly clean layers, but some effects or brushes may not translate perfectly; Photoshop handles PSDs natively and plays nicer with other Adobe apps for teams.
Cost is worth thinking about: Procreate is a flat one time fee, while Photoshop is monthly or yearly through Creative Cloud. If you're just starting, the upfront price can tilt the decision.
Try a tiny two week mini project in each program and compare how fast you can get a result you like, how comfortable your line work feels, and how easily you can organize layers and color palettes.